flowmade-one/architecture
3
0
Fork 0
Code Issues 15 Pull Requests 1 Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

[Issue #56] Create software-architecture skill #61

Merged
HugoNijhuis merged 1 commits from issue-56-software-architecture-skill into main 2026-01-09 23:07:47 +00:00
Conversation 2 Commits 1 Files Changed 1 +495
HugoNijhuis commented 2026-01-09 23:04:21 +00:00
Owner
Copy Link

Summary

Creates the foundational software-architecture skill that encodes best practices, review checklists, and patterns. This skill serves as the knowledge base for the software-architect agent and architecture-related commands.

Closes #56

Changes

  • Added skills/software-architecture/SKILL.md with:
    • Go-specific best practices (package organization, interfaces, error handling, DI, testing)
    • Generic architecture patterns (layered architecture, SOLID, dependency direction, module boundaries)
    • Repository health indicators (positive indicators, warning signs, metrics)
    • Review checklists (repo audit, issue refinement, PR review)
    • Anti-patterns to flag (god packages, circular deps, leaky abstractions, anemic domain model, shotgun surgery, feature envy, premature abstraction, deep hierarchy)
    • Skill marked as user-invocable: false in frontmatter
## Summary Creates the foundational software-architecture skill that encodes best practices, review checklists, and patterns. This skill serves as the knowledge base for the software-architect agent and architecture-related commands. Closes #56 ## Changes - Added skills/software-architecture/SKILL.md with: - Go-specific best practices (package organization, interfaces, error handling, DI, testing) - Generic architecture patterns (layered architecture, SOLID, dependency direction, module boundaries) - Repository health indicators (positive indicators, warning signs, metrics) - Review checklists (repo audit, issue refinement, PR review) - Anti-patterns to flag (god packages, circular deps, leaky abstractions, anemic domain model, shotgun surgery, feature envy, premature abstraction, deep hierarchy) - Skill marked as user-invocable: false in frontmatter
HugoNijhuis added 1 commit 2026-01-09 23:04:22 +00:00
Add software-architecture skill 8ed646857a 
Creates the foundational skill that encodes software architecture
best practices, review checklists, and patterns for Go and generic
architecture guidance.

Closes #56

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
HugoNijhuis merged commit 8ed646857a into main 2026-01-09 23:07:47 +00:00
HugoNijhuis commented 2026-01-09 23:43:18 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy Link

AI Code Review

LGTM - All acceptance criteria met. Comprehensive software architecture skill with accurate Go best practices, generic patterns, practical checklists, and well-documented anti-patterns.

## AI Code Review LGTM - All acceptance criteria met. Comprehensive software architecture skill with accurate Go best practices, generic patterns, practical checklists, and well-documented anti-patterns.
HugoNijhuis commented 2026-01-09 23:57:24 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy Link

AI Code Review

This is an automated review generated by the code-review agent.

Summary

This PR delivers a comprehensive, well-structured software architecture skill that successfully addresses all acceptance criteria from issue #56. The content is accurate, practical, and immediately actionable for architecture reviews.

Findings

Code Quality

  • SKILL.md is excellently organized with clear hierarchy and logical flow
  • Go code examples are idiomatic and demonstrate best practices accurately
  • ASCII diagrams for layered architecture and dependency direction are clear and helpful
  • Consistent formatting and structure throughout all sections
  • Good balance between being comprehensive and remaining focused

Content Accuracy - Go Best Practices

  • Package organization guidance is spot-on (cmd/, internal/, pkg/ structure)
  • Interface advice follows Go proverbs correctly ("accept interfaces, return structs", "consumer owns interface")
  • Error handling patterns are accurate (wrap with %w, sentinel errors, error types)
  • Dependency injection guidance promotes explicit dependencies and avoids globals
  • Table-driven test example follows Go testing conventions perfectly
  • No technical inaccuracies found

Content Accuracy - Generic Patterns

  • Layered architecture diagram correctly shows dependency flow
  • SOLID principles are explained concisely and accurately
  • Dependency direction diagram clearly illustrates the dependency inversion principle
  • Module boundary guidance is practical and recognizable
  • All patterns are explained at the right level of detail for a review skill

Review Checklists Usefulness

  • Three checklists (repo audit, issue refinement, PR review) cover distinct use cases
  • Checklist items are specific, actionable, and measurable
  • Repository health indicators provide concrete warning signs (e.g., "20+ files", "4+ levels nesting")
  • Positive indicators balance the warning signs well
  • Checklists will be immediately useful for software-architect agent

Anti-Patterns Documentation

  • Eight anti-patterns documented with Problem/Symptoms/Fix structure
  • Examples are realistic and commonly encountered
  • Fixes are actionable and specific
  • Good coverage: god packages, circular deps, leaky abstractions, anemic domain, shotgun surgery, feature envy, premature abstraction, deep hierarchy
  • The "god packages" example with specific fix (extract validation, httputil, timeutil) is particularly helpful

Completeness Against Acceptance Criteria

  • Skill file at skills/software-architecture/SKILL.md
  • Go-specific best practices (package org, interfaces, errors, DI, testing)
  • Generic architecture patterns (layered, SOLID, dependency direction, module boundaries)
  • Repository health indicators (positive indicators, warning signs, metrics)
  • Review checklists (repo audit, issue refinement, PR review)
  • Anti-patterns documented (8 comprehensive examples)
  • user-invocable: false in frontmatter

All acceptance criteria fully satisfied.

Style Notes

Consistent with existing skills in the codebase. Frontmatter follows skill conventions.

Test Coverage

Not applicable - this is documentation. The skill will be validated through usage by the software-architect agent and architecture commands.

Positive Highlights

  1. The "define interfaces at point of use" section with side-by-side good/bad examples is exceptionally clear
  2. Repository health indicators table format makes scanning for issues very efficient
  3. Anti-pattern structure (Problem/Symptoms/Fix) provides excellent guidance for both detection and remediation
  4. The dependency direction diagram with the "key insight" annotation is a great teaching moment
  5. Code examples are minimal but complete - easy to understand at a glance

Verdict

LGTM - Ready to Merge

This is excellent foundational work. The skill is comprehensive, accurate, and immediately actionable. It provides exactly the knowledge base needed for the software-architect agent and architecture commands. No changes needed.

## AI Code Review > This is an automated review generated by the code-review agent. ### Summary This PR delivers a comprehensive, well-structured software architecture skill that successfully addresses all acceptance criteria from issue #56. The content is accurate, practical, and immediately actionable for architecture reviews. ### Findings #### Code Quality - SKILL.md is excellently organized with clear hierarchy and logical flow - Go code examples are idiomatic and demonstrate best practices accurately - ASCII diagrams for layered architecture and dependency direction are clear and helpful - Consistent formatting and structure throughout all sections - Good balance between being comprehensive and remaining focused #### Content Accuracy - Go Best Practices - Package organization guidance is spot-on (cmd/, internal/, pkg/ structure) - Interface advice follows Go proverbs correctly ("accept interfaces, return structs", "consumer owns interface") - Error handling patterns are accurate (wrap with %w, sentinel errors, error types) - Dependency injection guidance promotes explicit dependencies and avoids globals - Table-driven test example follows Go testing conventions perfectly - No technical inaccuracies found #### Content Accuracy - Generic Patterns - Layered architecture diagram correctly shows dependency flow - SOLID principles are explained concisely and accurately - Dependency direction diagram clearly illustrates the dependency inversion principle - Module boundary guidance is practical and recognizable - All patterns are explained at the right level of detail for a review skill #### Review Checklists Usefulness - Three checklists (repo audit, issue refinement, PR review) cover distinct use cases - Checklist items are specific, actionable, and measurable - Repository health indicators provide concrete warning signs (e.g., "20+ files", "4+ levels nesting") - Positive indicators balance the warning signs well - Checklists will be immediately useful for software-architect agent #### Anti-Patterns Documentation - Eight anti-patterns documented with Problem/Symptoms/Fix structure - Examples are realistic and commonly encountered - Fixes are actionable and specific - Good coverage: god packages, circular deps, leaky abstractions, anemic domain, shotgun surgery, feature envy, premature abstraction, deep hierarchy - The "god packages" example with specific fix (extract validation, httputil, timeutil) is particularly helpful #### Completeness Against Acceptance Criteria - [x] Skill file at skills/software-architecture/SKILL.md - [x] Go-specific best practices (package org, interfaces, errors, DI, testing) - [x] Generic architecture patterns (layered, SOLID, dependency direction, module boundaries) - [x] Repository health indicators (positive indicators, warning signs, metrics) - [x] Review checklists (repo audit, issue refinement, PR review) - [x] Anti-patterns documented (8 comprehensive examples) - [x] user-invocable: false in frontmatter All acceptance criteria fully satisfied. #### Style Notes Consistent with existing skills in the codebase. Frontmatter follows skill conventions. #### Test Coverage Not applicable - this is documentation. The skill will be validated through usage by the software-architect agent and architecture commands. ### Positive Highlights 1. The "define interfaces at point of use" section with side-by-side good/bad examples is exceptionally clear 2. Repository health indicators table format makes scanning for issues very efficient 3. Anti-pattern structure (Problem/Symptoms/Fix) provides excellent guidance for both detection and remediation 4. The dependency direction diagram with the "key insight" annotation is a great teaching moment 5. Code examples are minimal but complete - easy to understand at a glance ### Verdict **LGTM - Ready to Merge** This is excellent foundational work. The skill is comprehensive, accurate, and immediately actionable. It provides exactly the knowledge base needed for the software-architect agent and architecture commands. No changes needed.
Sign in to join this conversation.
Reviewers
No Reviewers
Labels
No items
No Label
Milestone
No items
No Milestone
Projects
Clear projects
No project
Assignees
Clear assignees
HugoNijhuis fluxcd-bot renovate-bot
No Assignees
1 Participants
Notifications
Due Date
No due date set.
Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: flowmade-one/architecture#61
Delete Branch "issue-56-software-architecture-skill"

Deleting a branch is permanent. Although the deleted branch may continue to exist for a short time before it actually gets removed, it CANNOT be undone in most cases. Continue?